• Live
    • Audio Only
  • google plus
  • facebook
  • twitter
News > Brazil

Brazil Mining Regulator Says Vale 'Negligence' Cost Lives

  • On January 25, Brazil experienced its most deadly mining accident.

    On January 25, Brazil experienced its most deadly mining accident. | Photo: Reuters

Published 5 November 2019

The regulator’s report on its probe into the disaster is the latest blow to the reputation of Vale, which is under criminal investigation over accusations that top executives ignored warning signs about the dam.

Brazil’s mining regulator on Tuesday blasted iron ore miner Vale SA for failing to disclose problems with a mining dam before a deadly collapse in January, saying this kept the agency from taking actions that could have saved lives.

Death Toll in Brazil Dam Collapse Rises to 250: New Findings

The dam in Brumadinho collapsed and flooded a nearby company cafeteria and the surrounding countryside with mining waste, killing more than 250 people. It was Vale’s second deadly dam collapse in less than four years.

Based on the report’s findings, ANM will now assess the iron ore miner with 24 new fines. Officials said that the amount of each fine is capped at around 6,000 reais (US$1,500) under Brazilian law.

The report detailed several problems that it said Vale should have reported.

The first occurred in June 2018, seven months before the disaster, when the company installed horizontal drainage pipes and discovered sediment in the drainage water. This worrying sign should have been reported immediately, ANM officials told reporters in a briefing.

“The serious fact is that when there is sediment it must be reported. Period. It wasn’t. If it had been communicated, the area would immediately have been submitted to daily inspections,” said ANM head Victor Bicca. “But we didn’t know what was happening.”

Vale said in a statement it would analyze the report but it was unable to comment on technical decisions taken by its “geotechnical team” at the time.

Several ANM directors said if Vale had properly reported drainage, water pressure and other issues at the dam, it would have been classified as “emergency level 1”, bringing a higher level of scrutiny including daily inspections.

They said those inspections could have uncovered further problems, ultimately leading to evacuation, which would have saved lives.

Because problems were not disclosed, the dam was not given high priority, since it was not actively receiving more mining waste, director Tasso Mendonca said. He said the dam was “a bit forgotten.”

Moreover, a congressional report disclosed on Tuesday found that several Vale executives received an anonymous email in January 2019 warning about the coming disaster, saying that the dam was "at the verge" of its capacity.

But instead of investigating the defectuous dam, the executives ordered other employees to investigate the source of the email, said the 625-page report, writen by congressman Rogerio Correira.

A Vale spokesperson responded that the company did not find relevant investigating "groundless claims."

Post with no comments.